WIMBLEDON: Serena Williams or Kim Clijsters, Who had Better Comeback? Also, Wimby Grades, More on Court 2

 

Serena Williams

A few random thoughts and grades on Wimbledon.

Serena Williams is stealing the tournament. Her touching tears of joy after her first round followed by her complaints about being shoved to an outer court after her second round and then her complete domination in the third round, with this proclamation:

“Don’t bet against me.’’

The idea that this is an amazing comeback, after a year away with foot injury and then illness, is hard to argue with. But I always thought she was going to win the tournament anyway. She’s great. The rest of the tour is not. Two statements are being made here.

The question is this: Which is the more amazing comeback? Williams’ or Kim Clijsters?

Clijsters retired for a while, then had a baby, then came back. After two warmup tournaments, she won the U.S. Open. Williams had two surgeries, she said, for cut ligaments in her foot. Then, forced to sit around while she healed, blood clots formed and worked their way up into her lungs. She played one warmup tournament.

To be totally honest, I don’t think I’m in the best position to be answering the question here. I think Clijsters’ comeback was a little tougher, but I’m also not overly well-versed in exactly what damage is done to the body by having a baby.

Any mothers out there would know better. So I ask you.

I asked my own mother, and also my wife. Both said Serena’s comeback, if she wins Wimbledon, is tougher. Both felt for someone in fantastic shape, as Clijsters was in, recovering from having a baby isn’t that rough. I also asked Chris Evert, who thought Serena’s comeback would be more impressive than Clijsters’.

It’s true, too, that Clijsters left by her choice. She refreshed her mind, recharged her batteries and came back when she felt like it. Williams was forced to take time way, and had the stress of not knowing when, or if, she’d come back.

But Clijsters beat Venus, Serena and current No. 1 Caroline Wozniacki in her comeback. Now, with Clijsters out hurt, and Venus nearly two years older, Serena’s path isn’t quite as hard.

  1. Also, Clijsters’ comeback was more shocking, as she wasn’t nearly as great a player when she left as Serena was. Clijsters dominated tennis in a way she had never done before. Williams, if she wins, is simply back to where she was before. I guess I’m asking this: A baby or a blood clot. Which is more painful?

What do you think?

 

YOUNG GUNS: Impressive play by Bernard Tomic, beating Robin Soderling and reaching the fourth round. At just 18, he should be able to beat Xavier Malisse to reach the quarters. He keeps fooling me. I watched him play a thrilling match at the 2009 Australian Open, and figured he was a surefire star. By the 2010 Aussie Open, he seemed to have lost his work ethic, so I figured he wasn’t that great afterall.

Now, one step ahead of me again, he is emerging right here, right now.

I guess I’ll jinx him here: He’s going to be great.

With Milos Raonic and Alexandr Dolgoplov, the next generation is lined up perfectly. And that’s not even counting Juan Martin del Potro, who’s only 22, but already a U.S. Open champ. The question is whether Ryan Harrison is going to be in that group. He jumped several levels by going five sets with David Ferrer in the second round before losing. But there are several more levels to go.

 

COURT 2: After Serena griped about being put on Court 2 – and she was right —  Wozniacki also said she would like to be on a main court. Well, Wozniacki is ranked No. 1, but she got Centre Court last year over Serena on the day the Queen came to visit Wimbledon for the first time in decades. Not sure Wozniacki has a legitimate beef.

Some writers have credited Venus Williams for saying that Court 2 is a fine court. Yes, but she also said she just doesn’t like to make her arguments through the press. I still think a snooty white club trying to live in the past cannot just throw two legendary black players onto an outer court. No way.

 

QUICK GRADES:

 

A

 

Wozniacki: Has anyone mentioned the No. 1 player’s name during the tournament? Serena has completely overshadowed her, which is good for Wozniacki. No one is even mentioning that she doesn’t deserve to be No. 1 because she hasn’t won a major. But Wozniacki is playing great. Always looking to prove she’s a real champ, she could do that in the next few days. Imagine her beating Maria Sharapova, then Serena, then Venus to win Wimbledon. Doubts. Gone.

Serena Williams: Playing great. Ready to win. Look for her to play next on the plastic grass courts at the public park across the street from the club.

Rafael Nadal: Same as Serena, only on Centre Court.

Venus Williams: In some ways, her comeback is even better than Serena’s. Age was becoming a factor before her injuries.

Roger Federer: Looking a lot like his old self, moving well. The deep feeling that he can’t beat Nadal, though, must still be there.

 

B

Ryan Harrison: Five sets before losing to David Ferrer. That was impressive for a 19-year old. Not impressive was that in the qualifying tournament, which he lost, he broke racquets and took divots out of the court. He was fined, but got a lucky-loser entry into his second straight major.

 

C

Andy Roddick: With everything lined up perfectly for one of those late-career miracle runs, he lost to career-choker Feliciano Lopez. Roddick had beaten Lopez every time they played. Had he won that match, he would have played a qualifier to get into the quarters. Roddick is done winning majors. The only reason his grade isn’t lower is that Lopez does have a lot of talent and played one of the best matches of his life.

Bethanie Mattek-Sands: The wild outfits and appearance are fun. But when you lose to some qualifier, it looks clown-like.

 

D

Li Na: French Open champ lost early, took half of Wimbledon’s potential world audience with her

Sam Stosur: I thought she would be great someday. Now she’s too scared to hit a backhand and won’t bother coming to the net despite being a strong volleyer.

My predictions: OK, I wasn’t duped by the idea that Serena would be rusty. She and Nadal are on track for winning, as I predicted. But I also picked Melanie Oudin to beat Ana Ivanovic. Instead, she won 1 game.

 

D-minus

Oudin: Thanks a lot, Melanie.

 

F

Wimbledon scheduling people. Venus and Serena are Wimbledon legends. They should build statues to them, not put them on outer courts. As Venus put it, Court 2 is fine, as long as everyone has to go out there sometimes.

Tennis computers: Gearing up for the ultimate embarrassment: If Nadal beats Novak Djokovic in the final, then Nadal will have won five of the past six majors. He will have beaten Djokovic in two finals. Djoker will never have beaten Nadal in a major. And the next day, No. 2 Djokovic will jump No. 1 Nadal in the rankings.

 

 

About gregcouch

I can talk tennis all day long, and often do. And yet some of the people I talk to about it might rather I talk about something else. Or with someone else. That’s how it is with tennis, right? Sort of an addiction. Sort of a high. I am a national columnist at FoxSports.com and a FoxSports1 TV insider, and have been a columnist at the Chicago Sun-Times. In 2010, I was the only American sports writer to cover the full two weeks of all four majors, and also to cover each of the U.S. Masters series events. I’ve seen a lot of tennis, talked with a lot of players, coaches, agents. I watched from a few rows behind the line judge as Serena rolled her foot onto the baseline for the footfault, a good call, at the 2009 U.S. Open. I sat forever watching a John Isner marathon, leaving for Wimbledon village to watch an England World Cup soccer game at a pub and then returning for hours of Isner, sitting a few feet from his wrecked coach. I got to see Novak Djokovic and Robin Soderling joke around on a practice court on the middle Sunday at Wimbledon, placing a small wager on a tiebreaker. Djokovic won, and Soderling pulled a bill out of his wallet, crumpled it into his fist and threw it at Djokovic, who unwadded it, kissed it, and told me, “My work is done here.’’ And when Rafael Nadal won the French Open in 2010, I finished my column, walked back out onto the court, and filled an empty tic tac container with the red clay. I’m looking at it right now. Well, I don’t always see the game the same way others do. I can be hard on tennis, particularly on the characters in suits running it. Tennis has no less scandal and dirt than any other game. Yet somehow, it seems to be covered up, usually from an incredible web of conflicts of interest. I promise to always tell the truth as I see it. Of course, I would appreciate it if you’d let me know when I’m wrong. I love sports arguments and hope to be in a few of them with you here. Personal info: One-handed backhand, serve-and-volleyer. View all posts by gregcouch

4 responses to “WIMBLEDON: Serena Williams or Kim Clijsters, Who had Better Comeback? Also, Wimby Grades, More on Court 2

  • michelle lilting

    I don’t even know why there is a debate about this? Having a baby is not an anomaly, an illness, or a disease! Blood clots on the lungs do qualify as such. Kim Clijsters wasn’t recovering from injury. There have been women who won gold medals in track and field events at the Olympics after marrying and having babies. In fact, there are many women who have stated that after the ( at the time) seemingly superhuman feat of giving birth, they feel as if they can do ANYTHING! Giving birth -particularly the old-fashioned way is tough — but it is natural. Blood clots on the lungs and severed tendons in the foot are NOT. Clijsters coming back from a nice rest is not even in the same category. In fact, Serena’s comeback to win the Australian Open is more impressive than Clister’s. Serena had been injured, bereaved – because of her beloved sister’s death – AND emotionally drained because of a lawsuit JUST before that Australian Open. Serena’s spiritual and mental strength and ability to persevere are amazing. She makes me proud to be an
    American.

  • Maxshade7

    I agree that Serena might have had more to overcome but Kim had the better comeback. Kim actually won the US Open after coming back. Serena hasnt done that yet.

  • Basque

    It would be nice if you finally recognized the Williams are just humans, and you just cannot expect them to land after months of serious injuries and walk away with the title. Also, bear in mind Pironkova is a player that had previously twice beaten Venus at GS tournaments, the last one at Wimbledon and that Bartoli is fresh from a RG semifinal and an Eastbourne victory, so I still don’t get why you were oozing that much confidence. Add Sharapova’s still shaky mental attitude and you’ll have a new champion, me thinks. Who’s your bet? Kvitova?

  • michelle lilting

    Maxshade7, Serena had already given us a much greater comeback than Clijsters’ when she (Serena) won the Australian Open trophy years ago after just coming back from mourning the death of her beloved sister, after recuperating from injury, and after having just been through an emotionally tough lawsuit – which was not ONLY emotionally-draining but which seriously curtailed her practice time leading up to the tournament! Kim just had a baby and a nice long vacation. Btw, why doesn’t Couch have snide remarks about Kim “laying out” for long periods — clearly resting up for SOME majors — like the U.S. Open. Serena has actually had a REAL injury (which Couch was stupidly in “disbelief” about) which resulted in BLOOD CLOTS on her LUNG, but Clijsters gets a free pass and NO “suspicion” from him when she has had NO surgery nor any other REAL proof of injury? Interesting. And BIGOTED!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: